Hello dear
Welcome to Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant
At Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant, the heart of Italian cuisine thrives in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Nestled in Staten Island, this beloved eatery combines classic old-school Italian dishes with a modern touch. From generously portioned pasta like Baked Ziti and creamy Fettuccini Alfredo to their renowned pizzas, each dish is crafted with a commitment to authentic flavors. Regular patrons rave about the attentive service and the comforting vibe, making it an ideal spot for families and gatherings. With options for delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, Cafe Milano beautifully captures the essence of communal dining while offering an unforgettable culinary experience.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Deep Pan Pizza - Calamari
Deep Pan Pizza - Broccoli rabe and Sausage
Deep Pan Pizza - Eggplant
Deep Pan Pizza - Chicken Vodka
About
Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant
Welcome to Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant, your local gateway to authentic Italian flavors nestled right in the heart of Staten Island. Located at 401 Forest Ave, this vibrant eatery is a must-visit for anyone craving the classic taste of Italy. Known for its warm, inviting atmosphere, Cafe Milano excels in providing a delightful dining experience for families, friends, and groups alike.
Cafe Milano is a culinary gem in the realm of Italian cuisine, especially renowned for its pizza. As you step inside, you are greeted by a classy, casual vibe that resonates with patrons of all ages. With a full bar, outdoor seating, and gender-neutral restrooms, the restaurant ensures a comfortable environment for everyone. The moderate noise level fosters a friendly yet lively ambiance that makes it perfect for both casual hangouts and festive gatherings.
When it comes to their menu, the offerings are expansive and enticing. From delicious appetizers like Fried Calamari and Baked Clams to a variety of salads, the options are sure to please. Customers rave about the renowned Calamari, best ordered in a paper bag to maintain its crispness, a tip shared by loyal patrons. The highlight, of course, is the pizza—an experience that transports you back in time, reminiscent of the delightful bite you’d expect from a cartoon slice enjoyed during your childhood.
- Signature Dishes:
- Penne Vodka
- Chicken Francese
- Various pizza options, including the iconic Vodka Chicken slice
- Desserts:
- American Cheesecake
- Tiramisu
- Cannoli
Compliment your meal with one of their mouthwatering desserts, such as the Mississippi Mud Cake or the classic Tiramisu, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth after a hearty meal. Customers appreciate the generous portions at excellent prices, making it clear why Cafe Milano is considered a favorite among locals for years.
With options for delivery and takeout, you can enjoy these delightful dishes from the comfort of your home. Whether you’re hosting a gathering or just seeking a cozy dinner with family, Cafe Milano’s catering services and group-friendly atmosphere make it a reliable choice. The positive reviews highlight the attentive service and a menu that reflects a true dedication to quality and tradition.
As you explore Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant, you're not just indulging in exceptional food; you're experiencing the warmth of old-school Italian hospitality. So why not gather your loved ones and dive into a taste of Italy today? Your taste buds will thank you!
For reservations, catering, or simply to place an order, call them at (718) 720-1313. Let Cafe Milano be your go-to destination for delightful Italian cuisine!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ My go-to for years. I have had them cater numerous events over the years. The service is above reproach. This is old school Italian food. If you want a Michelin star, go elsewhere. Generously portioned and excellent prices. They taught me to order calamari in a paper bag, so that it doesn't lose the crispness. Family who grew up here and since moved, LOVE the Cafe Milano fare. The atmosphere is warm and friendly. ”
“ Excellent pizza, order often for delivery. Consistently good food & reliable. Prompt delivery service ”
“ Delicious penne vodka, chicken francese and the pizza. Plenty of tables to sit and enjoy your food in a comfortable and clean atmosphere. Excellent customer service, as well. Support your local small business. ”
“ Ever wondered what 90s cartoon pizza tasted like (TMNT, Goofy Movie)? This is what I'd imagine. Medium cheese comes out perfect. My go to spot. ”
“ Stopped by for a bite to eat on a Monday afternoon and the place was pretty quiet. There is a separate dining area next to the pizzeria so there's plenty of seating to go around. I ordered a square slice ($3.55) to go and the dough was quite puffy and soft. The mozzarella cheese tasted a little congealed so I would have liked for the slice to be warmed up a little more. Would definitely go back to try a grandma slice, but I am told their vodka chicken slice is phenomenal. ”
“ Fresh, crunchy, delicious, and delivered HOT!! Super easy to order online. Husband actually received their menu from the Cafe Milano delivery driver while he was delivering pizza to one of our neighbors. We happened to be on the lookout for a new pizza place to call our own - and we found it. Thank you!! Will absolutely order from again. ”
